Welcome to our big toothpaste without fluoride test 2019. Here we present you the toothpastes without fluoride tested by us. We have compiled detailed background information for you and also added a summary of customer reviews on the net.
We want to make your purchase decision easier and help you find the best fluoride-free toothpaste for you.
You can also find answers to frequently asked questions in our guide. If available, we also offer you interesting test videos. You will also find some important information on this page, which you should pay attention to if you want to buy a toothpaste without fluoride.
The most important in brief
- Dental care with toothpaste or other tooth cleaning agents is indispensable for healthy oral hygiene – but fluoride does not necessarily have to be present.
- A basic distinction is made between universal toothpaste, sensitive toothpaste and toothpaste with a whitening effect. The former is suitable for the everyday caries prophylaxis of people with naturally good oral hygiene. Toothpaste with a whitening effect removes plaque and deposits and whitens teeth. Sensitive toothpaste strengthens gums and teeth and is particularly suitable for people with pain-sensitive teeth.
- The ingredients of toothpaste are now important. You want to do without harmful ingredients, such as the criticized fluoride, and still find a good toothpaste.
Toothpaste without Fluoride Test: The Ranking
Place 1: Himalaya Herbals Mint Fresh Toothpaste 75 ml
The toothpaste from Himalaya Herbals is not only free of fluoride, it is also vegan. With fennel, mint, Indian dil, cloves and miswak it cleans teeth and promotes healthy gums.
Himalaya Herbals promises the customer a 100% organic product whose ingredients are not subjected to any hard extraction processes that could reduce quality.
Customers particularly appreciate the fresh, pleasant mint taste of Himalaya Herbals toothpaste, which remains in the mouth long after application.
2nd place: Neem & pomegranate toothpaste, 150g
This product from Himalaya Organique with the ingredients neem and pomegranate extract not only thoroughly clean the teeth, but also effective against gum inflammation and gum bleeding to work.
The product contains no fluoride, no parabens, no saccharin, no sodium lauryl sulphate (SLS) and no sodium laureth sulphate (SLES). With its filling quantity of 150g it belongs to the exceptional products among toothpastes in tubes.
Customers particularly appreciate Neem & Pomegranate toothpaste’s easy-to-dispense consistency, slightly sweet, fresh taste and clean feeling on the teeth after use.
3rd place: Forever Bright toothgel Aloe Vera toothgel, 130g
Aloe Vera toothpaste by Forever Bright from the USA gently cleans teeth and is particularly suitable for sensitive teeth and irritated gums. It protects the enamel, strengthens the gums and prevents the formation of gums. This is achieved through the combination of aloe vera and propolis.
Customers particularly appreciate the pleasant gel consistency and the fresh taste of aloe vera, which is often described as “mild” and therefore also suitable for sensitive oral mucosa.
What is toothpaste without fluoride?
As the name suggests, this toothpaste does not contain the mineral fluoride. Fluoride is mainly used in toothpaste to fight tooth decay.
Toothpastes without fluoride are added other substances to achieve an effect that prevents tooth decay it fights.
Some fluoride-free toothpastes use hydroxyapatite, the main component of the tooth, to mimic the caries-fighting effect of fluoride. However, the success of this method is sometimes controversial.
What distinguishes a toothpaste without fluoride?
Fluoride in toothpaste doesn’t have to be. Even without fluoride, the teeth can be thoroughly cleaned and even without fluoride, toothpaste can contain substances against tooth problems.
But also other chemical ingredients, apart from fluoride, can be harmful. However, many toothpastes without fluoride are available with natural ingredients – especially the Zero-Waste varieties, of which there is now a wide selection.
If you have a problem with tooth decay, you should not use toothpaste without fluoride. Although there are manufacturers who promise caries control without fluoride caries, this is not true.
Preventing tooth decay is quite possible. However, there are no reliable results for substances that can imitate the effect of fluoride in the fight against tooth decay.
If you generally have an increased risk of tooth decay, then tooth care with toothpaste without fluoride would not reduce this risk, but rather increase it even further. Because even the best toothpaste can do nothing against the food we eat.
In such cases other measures may be necessary for an optimal dental protection without fluoride. For example, a change in diet, mouthwashes, oiling or similar.
Especially for people who want to live sustainably, a fluoride-free toothpaste is probably the more attractive option in any case – because such a toothpaste can easily be made by yourself.
This video will show you how it works:
For whom is toothpaste without fluoride suitable?
The caries risk is an individually very different matter. It is influenced by factors such as oral hygiene and nutrition – but also by genes.
Therefore, you should consult your dentist to find out if you are very susceptible to tooth decay or not.
Toothpaste without fluoride is particularly suitable for children – but also for adults who have no increased risk of tooth decay or no current problem with tooth decay.
Is toothpaste without fluoride suitable for pain-sensitive teeth?
A toothpaste without fluoride is basically suitable for everyone. However, every mouth is different and needs a product that is tailored to individual oral hygiene. When choosing your toothpaste you should therefore pay attention to the condition of your teeth and gums and choose a product that meets the needs of your teeth.
Toothpaste without fluoride is good for everyone who wants a thorough tooth cleaning, caries prevention, strengthening of the gums and a fresh mouth feeling. If you also value natural ingredients, fluoride-free toothpaste is ideal because it often does not contain any chemical additives.
Dr. Kim SchreiberDentist
The supply of too much fluoride can lead to so-called tooth fluorosis. It is noticeable by whitish spots on the teeth. The milk teeth are particularly susceptible to this clinical picture. These discolorations can be removed by a dentist.
However, if your teeth are very sensitive to pain and you have severe enamel problems, it is advisable to use a toothpaste that contains fluoride.
Here, too, there are alternatives from natural cosmetics that are produced on the basis of natural ingredients.
Is toothpaste without fluoride suitable for children?
Toothpaste without fluoride is also recommended for children. However, the opinions of doctors and dentists differ as to whether it is better to use fluoride or not.
Pediatricians advocate taking fluoride tablets and not using fluoride-containing toothpaste, because otherwise too much of it will be swallowed and an overdose may occur.
Dentists, on the other hand, agree that fluoride must be applied directly to the tooth in order to be effective.
Parents must therefore decide for themselves which dosage form is right for their child. A fluoride toothpaste for children should always be used under the supervision of mum or dad.
What is the difference between toothpaste with and without fluoride?
First and foremost, the intended use is different. In the case of fluoride toothpaste, it is caries prophylaxis.
Caries is caused by acids – and these acids are caused by bacteria that reach the teeth through food intake. These acids dissolve the tooth (demineralisation) and fluoride is supposed to stop this process by remineralisation.
Of course, this also means that someone who is not susceptible to caries or has no problem with caries does not need toothpaste with fluoride when cleaning his teeth. If you still want to find out more about toothpastes with fluoride, you can find out here:
Where can I buy toothpaste without fluoride?
You can buy fluoride-free toothpaste in any supermarket that sells dental care products, in drugstores such as dm and Rossmann, and in pharmacies.
Health food stores and organic supermarkets also usually have a selection of fluoride-free toothpastes, which are then usually also packaged sustainably.
You can also find fluoride-free toothpaste in various online shops. Here is a small selection of the most common shops:
All toothpaste products without fluoride, which we present on our site, are provided with at least one link to one of these shops. If you have found a variant that you would like to try out, you can suggest it directly.
What does toothpaste cost without fluoride?
Our research has shown that the price of toothpaste without fluoride is not very different from toothpastes with fluoride. A general price analysis showed the following trends:
Thus the tendencies are similar to toothpastes with fluoride. The whole can be categorized then still further on the basis the packing size. Fluoride-free toothpaste is usually available in sample sizes of 25 ml and in tubes of 50 and 75 ml.
Naturally there are also some few exceptions with other filling quantities or other packing, for instance as chewing tablets in cardboard packing or as thick liquid paste in crucibles.
However, we will not take these exceptions into account in our price overview, as they are usually available in countries such as Sweden or the USA.
|25 ml||ca. 1 to 5$|
|50 ml||ca. 2 to 15$|
|75 ml||ca. 3 to 20$|
What are the alternatives?
Whether with or without fluoride – toothpaste is the most common means of tooth cleaning. You can also get both in other forms, such as zero-waste toothpaste or if you want to make sure your toothpaste is vegan and sustainable.
Dent-Tabs are an alternative. This is toothpaste in tablet form. You take a tablet in your mouth, chew it up and brush your teeth with the result. Please do not swallow! The advantage is that these tabs contain three times less ingredients than standard toothpastes.
|Dent-Tabs||Tablets that are chewed up and foam up in combination with saliva when brushing teeth. They contain a significantly lower dose of the ingredients compared to toothpaste in tubes.|
|Solid toothpaste||Solid toothpaste dissolves on contact with saliva or water. You only have to rub the toothpaste stick over your teeth and then you can brush your teeth normally.|
|Toothbrush Powder||Toothbrush powder works similar to Dent-Tabs, but has not been pressed into a tablet form and does not need to be chewed.|
|DIY||Toothpaste can also be easily made with natural ingredients. So you can definitely be sure that there is no fluoride in the toothpaste.|
Decision: What types of toothpastes are there and which one is right for you?
What types of toothpaste are there and what are the differences?
It’s hard to believe, but there are many different types of toothpaste, depending on how you categorize them. It’s not just “better” or “worse” – it depends on the purpose.
Basically, all toothpastes should have the same function: cleaning teeth thoroughly and preventing tooth decay. In addition, a long-lasting fresh mouth feeling should develop and the oral flora should be strengthened.
With the alternatives to toothpaste itself, we have already introduced you to various forms that a toothpaste can have. Apart from that, toothpastes can also be categorized according to their intended use:
- Universal toothpaste that cleans thoroughly and protects against tooth decay.
- Sensitive toothpaste for people with particularly pain-sensitive teeth
- Toothpaste with whitening effect for whitening teeth (either by chemical additives or activated carbon)
These toothpastes have special characteristics and are suitable for specific dental problems. We will show you them below to help you find the right toothpaste for you.
What distinguishes universal toothpaste and what are its advantages and disadvantages?
The universal toothpaste offers optimal protection against caries and removes discolorations and plaque. Bacteria, plaque and tartar are prevented. The cream also reliably protects against gingivitis and bad breath.
The universal toothpaste is easy to get, be it in the supermarket or in the drugstore. In addition, caries protection is already guaranteed at a particularly low price.
What distinguishes Sensitive Toothpaste and what are its advantages and disadvantages?
Sensitive toothpaste is ideal if you have pain-sensitive teeth. It is supposed to harden the enamel and has only little abrasion when brushing teeth. The paste is supposed to close the dentin tubules again, whereby open tooth necks can regenerate themselves.
Fluoride is added to most toothpastes in order to achieve an optimal effect.
Good products are available at low prices from discounters. However, you should pay attention to the list of ingredients. If you want to do without fluoride, you should inform yourself at the drugstore or pharmacy.
What makes white toothpaste so special and what are its advantages and disadvantages?
Whitening toothpaste helps you to remove strong stains from your teeth. These can be caused by food and cigarette smoking.
This toothpaste protects against tooth decay and provides a whitening effect through abrasion. Some small amounts of bleach are used to enhance the whitening effect.
Which of these species exist without fluoride?
In general, it can be said that every type of toothpaste – apart from DIY toothpaste, which is only possible without – is available with and without fluoride.
The different types of toothpaste are also available without fluoride, but the manufacturer promises to use them to combat tooth decay if you are careful.
With or without fluoride, you should definitely clean your teeth properly.
|How many times?||It is recommended by experts to clean your teeth at least twice a day. Once in the morning and once in the evening before sleeping. Depending on your diet, your teeth should also be cleaned during the day.|
|For how long?||So that you can also clean every spot thoroughly, you should also take enough time for it. Experts recommend a three-minute cleaning.|
|When?||The right time to brush your teeth is not right after eating, but half an hour later. Acidic foods and drinks attack the enamel. If you brush your teeth immediately after eating, you rub the minerals out of the enamel, making your teeth more prone to discoloration.|
Purchase criteria: Based on these factors you can compare and rate toothpastes without fluoride
Below we will show you which aspects you can choose for toothpaste without fluoride or an alternative.
The criteria you can use for comparison include:
- purpose of use
- tooth sensitivity
- price/performance ratio
In the following paragraphs we explain exactly what is important.
In addition to fluoride, a lot of other ingredients belong in a toothpaste – or not.
If you are unsure which of these substances you personally tolerate, consult a doctor. If you’re unsure about which substances besides fluoride can be harmful, or if a product that promises to be vegan is really vegan, apps like CodeCheck and ToxFox can help.
Especially when a toothpaste without fluoride promises to fight tooth decay, you should be careful.
The intended use will play an important role in your purchase decision. You will be asked whether you are looking for a toothpaste for everyday use, for white or pain-sensitive teeth.
The intended use is important to find the right product for you and to optimally protect your teeth and gums.
There are many test pages and forums on the Internet where you can read detailed reports including the opinions of independent testers.
Are your teeth particularly resistant to everyday stresses or particularly susceptible to tooth decay? Are they sensitive to pain or do they quickly form tartar? The texture of your teeth plays a decisive role in the choice of toothpaste.
It’s best to ask your dentist what toothpaste you need to keep your teeth healthy. For example, if you have no increased caries risk, you can use toothpaste without fluoride.
Most toothpastes are sold in plastic tubes. In the meantime, however, there are also many zero-waste variants with or without fluoride. Examples are:
- Cartons to slide on
- Crucibles made of glass or plastic
- Screw Lenses/Mason-Jars
- Handles (with cardboard outer packaging)
Another aspect that may seem important to you is sustainability. You should ask yourself if a company tests toothpastes on animals and if the product is vegan.
In order to create sustainability for nature as well, make sure that only natural ingredients are contained that can be biodegraded. Ask yourself whether the product contains microplastic or petroleum-based additives.
You can also make sure the packaging isn’t plastic. There are products that are packed with other materials. In addition, you can use a bamboo toothbrush or visit an unpacked store.
Toothpastes are available in all price ranges. Since the price tendencies between the variants are approximately the same, one can assume that for a toothpaste without fluoride no more must be paid than for a similar toothpaste with fluoride.
Thus the price/performance ratio is appropriate. Before you decide to buy such a toothpaste, you should still compare the prices. Depending on the retailer, there may be strong differences for the same product.
It is also worth mentioning that you can easily make your own natural, sustainable toothpaste without fluoride – which of course keeps costs down considerably in the long run compared to having to buy new tubes again and again. And it’s also more environmentally friendly.
Trivia: Facts worth knowing about toothpaste without fluoride
What is fluoride and why is it used in toothpaste?
Fluoride is a mineral, i.e. a salt, and a component of hydrofluoric acid. In 1802, scientists discovered that fluoride is also found in bones and teeth – and that it makes teeth more resistant to damage.
Did you know that some types of table salt also contain fluoride?
The additional intake of fluorides in the diet, in combination with the intake of dental care products, can lead even more frequently to an overdose.
The particularly small ions of fluoride are deposited in the crystal lattice of the hydroxyapatite of which the teeth are made, making it more stable. From 1874, fluoride was therefore added to toothpastes to combat damage such as tooth decay more effectively.
The limits for toothpastes sold in the EU were set in 1978 and have not changed since.
This threshold value is 0.05 mg per kilogram of body weight per day – but only a value of 5 mg per kilogram of body weight per day is toxic.
How does fluoride work against teeth that are sensitive to pain?
Acid attacks teeth by removing certain minerals from the enamel, including calcium and phosphorus. This creates open areas in the enamel grid of the tooth.
After a meal, saliva remineralises the teeth by releasing minerals into the teeth.
If too many acidic foods are consumed, the natural strengthening of the teeth gets out of balance. If fluoride is used from the outside, calcium is absorbed more quickly by the teeth. The fluoride is also stored in the tooth and forms a protective film around the tooth.
Why is fluoride criticized for being harmful?
Fluoride is highly reactive and therefore toxic even in small quantities. However, the fluoride contained in toothpaste is hardly reactive and less toxic.
Due to the toxic effect, fluorides have long been used as an ingredient in pesticides or even rat poison.
The authority also fears health problems in the population, especially since in the USA fluoride is even added to drinking water.
If one is exposed to a too high dose of fluoride over a longer period of time, bone fluorosis, for example, can occur. Severe cases of persons suffering from bone fluorosis were recorded in China and India in 2000.
About 200 million people in China and India consumed about 1 to 4 mg fluoride per litre daily through drinking water. In addition, fluoride poisoning can lead to kidney failure, brain damage, thyroid damage or even death.
In Europe such cases of poisoning by drinking water or food cannot usually occur – unless toothpaste is swallowed regularly after brushing instead of being spat out. Children are particularly at risk here.
This video explains in detail what fluoride is and whether it is really so harmful. The young woman also criticizes fluoride-free toothpastes that promise caries protection: